When Intuit shut down Mint in 2024, millions of people found out at the same moment that years of their financial history lived somewhere they didn’t control. They could export a CSV. They couldn’t keep the thing they’d built: the categories, the rules, the habits, the history in one place.
That’s not a story about one company. It’s how most money software works: your data lives on the vendor’s servers, in the vendor’s format, for as long as the vendor wants to keep the product going. There’s another way to build it.
What “local-first” means
Local-first software keeps your data on your own device, as the primary copy. The app works offline, opens instantly, and doesn’t need an account. If you want copies elsewhere, you send them there, on your terms.
For something as personal as your finances, that changes a lot.
It’s private by default
Your transactions describe your life: where you live, what you buy, who you pay, what you earn, when you’re struggling. A local app has no reason to collect any of it. There’s no analytics on your spending, no “anonymized” data sold to partners, and nothing for a breach to leak.
It doesn’t disappear
A file on your computer doesn’t get sunset, acquired, or moved to a new pricing plan. If the developer stopped tomorrow, the app on your machine would keep working, and your books would still be in your Documents folder.
You can see it, copy it and hand it over
Your books are a thing you can point to. Back it up like any other file. Copy it to a new computer. Hand it to your accountant at tax time.
“But what about my bank feed?”
Local-first doesn’t mean manual-only. A local app can still connect to your bank, as long as your books stay put. Tallybook’s bank sync runs through Tallybook Connect, a small service we run. It holds our Plaid keys, checks your plan, and passes your transactions straight to your computer without storing them. It keeps only an encrypted bank access token and your license key, so it can disconnect your banks when a plan ends. Your bank password goes only to Plaid’s sign-in page. The books themselves never leave your machine.
And when you’d rather not connect at all, nearly every bank lets you download a CSV or OFX/QFX statement. A good local app imports those safely, skipping duplicates when the dates overlap.
“And backups?”
This is the honest trade-off: if the data is yours, so is the backup. The answer is to make it easy, not to give the data away:
- Encrypt the file. With a strong key held in your system keychain, the file is unreadable to anyone who copies it, and you keep a recovery key for anywhere else.
- Send encrypted copies wherever you like: iCloud Drive, Dropbox, Google Drive, OneDrive, or a private Git repository. The cloud stores a sealed box it can’t open.
- Back up before every update, automatically.
What to look for in a private budgeting app
If you’re shopping for one, a few questions sort the local-first apps from the ones that merely say “secure”:
- Does it work without an account? If you have to sign up, your data is going somewhere.
- Where is the file? You should be able to find it, copy it and open it on another computer.
- Is it encrypted at rest, with a key you control?
- What does it send home? The right answer is close to nothing: an update check, and if the app offers bank sync, a plain account of what that service keeps and what it doesn’t.
- What happens if the company disappears? The app should keep working.
Why Tallybook works this way
We built Tallybook around these answers. Your household budget, bills and
goals, and if you run a business, your books and tax prep, live in one
.tallybook file on your computer. There’s no account. Encryption is one
click. Cloud copies are only ever sent encrypted. The household budget is free
for good. The paid plans are yearly, and if you stop paying, your books and
everything you unlocked keep working. Only bank sync and phone sync stop. Nothing
holds your history hostage.
Your money, in one file you own. Download it free.